Arrow-right Camera

Election Center


About this race

Six candidates are vying to replace retiring Supreme Court Judge Jim Jones. No matter which party voters select in partisan races, all voters may vote in the Supreme Court race.

Idaho Supreme Court, State of Idaho

846
Candidate Votes Pct
Robyn Brody (N) 39,534 30.98%
Curt McKenzie (N) 34,068 26.70%
Clive J. Strong (N) 27,123 21.26%
Sergio A. Gutierrez (N) 26,882 21.07%

* Race percentages are calculated with data from the Secretary of State's Office, which omits write-in votes from its calculations when there are too few to affect the outcome. The Spokane County Auditor's Office may have slightly different percentages than are reflected here because its figures include any write-in votes.


Related coverage

Idaho Supreme Court orders new trial for Mark Lankford in 33-year-old murder case

The Idaho Supreme Court has ordered a new trial for Mark Lankford in a 33-year-old murder case, ruling that prosecutors violated Lankford’s right to a fair trial. “As this court has noted many times, the right to a fair trial before an impartial jury is…


New director for courts, Brody’s fundraising edge, and what N.Idaho campaign $$ reports show…

From my Sunday column: Idaho’s court system has a new director after a two-year wait, Sara Thomas; Supreme Court hopeful Robyn Brody’s fundraising edge; and what the latest campaign finance reports show in North Idaho legislative races, including top fundraiser (Sen. Shawn Keough) and biggest debt (former Rep. Thyra Stevenson)…


Eye on Boise: After two-year wait, Idaho court system gets new director

Sara Thomas, Idaho’s state appellate public defender, has been named the new administrative director of Idaho’s courts by the Idaho Supreme Court.


State Appellate PD Sara Thomas named new administrative director of Idaho courts

The Idaho Supreme Court has named a new administrative director: Sara Thomas, who currently is the state appellate public defender. She’ll start her new job on July 11; the hire followed an extensive national search. Thomas replaces Patti Tobias, who served as administrative director of…


Court rejects reducing man’s life sentence for North Idaho killings

The Idaho Supreme Court denied a request for a reduced sentence made by a man convicted of killing his ex-wife and her boyfriend.


Latest water rights ruling from Idaho SupCourt rejects Rangen appeal

In a unanimous opinion authored by Chief Justice Jim Jones, the Idaho Supreme Court has rejected an appeal from Rangen Inc., which contended that a lower-court ruling upholding a water-rights mitigation plan was flawed; the plan called for several irrigation districts to divert 12 cubic…


It’ll be Brody vs. McKenzie in November for Idaho Supreme Court

It’ll be Brody vs. McKenzie in November in the race for the Idaho Supreme Court. With 917 of 938 precincts reporting – 98 percent – Rupert attorney Robyn Brody had 30 percent; state Sen. Curt McKenzie was in second place with 28 percent; and Clive…


Runoff set in Idaho SupCourt race, with Brody in the lead; full story

Here’s my full story from spokesman.com on the Idaho Supreme Court race: BOISE – A rare contested race for an open seat on the Idaho Supreme Court appears to be headed for a runoff in November, as none of the four hopefuls was polling over…


Runoff set in Idaho Supreme Court race, with Brody in the lead

A rare contested race for an open seat on the Idaho Supreme Court appears to be headed for a runoff in November, as none of the four hopefuls was polling over 50 percent in early returns Tuesday night – though Rupert attorney Robyn Brody was clearly out in front, with the other three neck-and-neck.


Brody, leading in Idaho Supreme Court race: ‘It’s an affirmation’

The only trend that’s been clear in results in the four-way Idaho Supreme Court race all night tonight: Robyn Brody has been out ahead all evening. The other three candidates have been neck-and-neck for second place. This guarantees a runoff in November, when the top…


Brody: ‘I feel like I’m waiting for a jury to come back’

Robyn Brody, candidate for the Idaho Supreme Court, stopped by both the Democratic and Republican party election-night gatherings this evening, with sons Jackson, 10, and Cooper, 8, in tow; she visited with voters, shook a few hands and mingled. She’s got her own election-night gathering…


Eye on Boise: Campaign finance dispute crops up in Idaho Supreme Court race

Robyn Brody’s campaign for the Idaho Supreme Court disputes a finding by the Idaho Secretary of Statethat four donations, totaling $27,000, received from four farm-related businesses exceeded the state Sunshine Law limits because the businesses are related by a single owner.


Brody campaign disputes Sunshine law interpretation, but sets aside $17K, points finger at Strong campaign

A spokesman for Robyn Brody’s campaign for the Idaho Supreme Court says the campaign is disputing the Idaho Secretary of State’s office’s finding that four donations, totaling $27,000, that it received from four farm-related firms exceeded the state Sunshine Law’s limits because the firms are…


Two candidates return contributions after running afoul of limits, including one for Idaho Supreme Court

Two candidates for state offices in the May 17 election are filing amended reports and returning contributions, after inadvertently running afoul of the Sunshine Law’s restrictions on donations from related entities, according to the Idaho Secretary of State’s office – including a candidate for the…


Of court candidates, endorsements, stepping on toes and fliers…

The Idaho Farm Bureau Federation’s endorsement of Curt McKenzie for an Idaho Supreme Court opening has raised some eyebrows, as the Farm Bureau is a nonprofit, which typically means an organization can’t support or oppose any candidate for public office. But Farm Bureau spokesman John…


Four Idaho Supreme Court candidates debate

Here’s a report from the Associated Press on tonight’s Idaho Supreme Court debate, in which four candidates for the state’s highest court debated judicial philosophy, endorsements, ethics and the role of the court. The debate was televised statewide on Idaho Public TV; it can be…


SupCourt hopefuls to face off tonight at 8 in televised debate

Tonight at 8, viewers across the state will have the opportunity to see all four of the candidates for the Idaho Supreme Court debate head-to-head as part of the “Idaho Debates” on Idaho Public Television. The four hopefuls – Rupert attorney Robyn Brody, Court of…


McKenzie releases endorsements; court candidates to debate Fri. night on statewide TV

Sen. Curt McKenzie, who is running in a four-way race for a nonpartisan position as a justice on the Idaho Supreme Court, called a press conference this week to announce his list of endorsements, who include 35 GOP state senators and representatives. McKenzie also said…


Idaho bar survey ranks three high court hopefuls highly, but not a fourth

Three of the candidates seeking an open Idaho Supreme Court seat were highly rated in a survey of members of the Idaho State Bar, but the fourth, state Sen. Curt McKenzie, drew much lower ratings from lawyers across the state, who rated the candidates on factors including integrity, independence, judicial temperament and legal experience.


State Bar survey finds Gutierrez, Brody tied for top scores, Strong second, McKenzie trailing way behind

The Idaho State Bar survey is out, surveying attorneys in Idaho about the four candidates for the Idaho Supreme Court. The results: Robyn Brody and Sergio Gutierrez tied for the top rankings, both getting an overall average score, statewide, of 3.58 out of 4. Clive…