September 27, 2012 in Features, Health

Doctor K: Supplement claims largely unproven

Anthony L. Komaroff Universal Uclick
 

DEAR DOCTOR K: Many herbs, vitamins and supplements claim to boost energy. Do any of them actually work?

DEAR READER: Unfortunately, there is not much scientific evidence to support the claims. Here is my best current assessment of the published evidence:

• Ginkgo biloba. It may improve alertness and calmness in healthy people. If you take a daily aspirin, or any other blood thinners, I’d avoid ginkgo. It may increase a bleeding tendency.

• Ginseng. This is a relatively safe herb, but there’s not much evidence that it reduces fatigue.

• Guarana. This herb induces a feeling of energy because it’s a natural source of caffeine. But consuming a lot of guarana could ultimately lower your energy by interfering with sleep.

• Chromium picolinate. This mineral is widely marketed to build muscle, burn fat, and increase energy and athletic performance. Research has not supported these claims.

• Vitamin B12. Some people take vitamin B12 as a way to get a quick energy burst. If you have a B12 deficiency, which is easy to determine with a simple blood test, treatment definitely can improve your energy.

• DHEA. This naturally occurring hormone is said to boost energy, among other things. But DHEA has no proven benefits and some potentially serious health risks. It is particularly wise to avoid it if you are pregnant or breast-feeding, have liver disease, polycystic ovarian syndrome, high blood levels of cholesterol or depression.

• Coenzyme Q10. This enzyme may improve exercise capacity in people with heart disease, and one small study found that people with chronic fatigue syndrome might benefit from this supplement. However, its value as a general energy booster is unproven.

• Creatine. Creatine is produced by the body and is largely found in muscle. There is evidence that it can build muscle mass and improve athletic performance requiring short bursts of muscle activity, particularly in teenagers and young adults (but not in older adults). However, it has not been proven to reduce fatigue. If you take creatine, stick to the recommended dose (2 to 3 grams per day).

Get stories like this in a free daily email


Please keep it civil. Don't post comments that are obscene, defamatory, threatening, off-topic, an infringement of copyright or an invasion of privacy. Read our forum standards and community guidelines.

You must be logged in to post comments. Please log in here or click the comment box below for options.

comments powered by Disqus